Stop sitting on customers' cash, minister to tell energy firms

Tory energy minister Greg Barker will demand to know why energy firms are hoarding up to £2bn from direct debit billpayers

Greg Barker
Greg Barker: 'I am determined to get consumers a better deal and call time on the big six sitting on customers’ cash'. Photograph: Martin Argles for the Guardian

The big six energy companies will on Tuesday be ordered to stop "sitting on customers' cash", as the government comes under pressure from Labour to deal with soaring household bills.

In an assault on overcharging by the utility companies, Greg Barker, a Tory energy minister, will demand to know why gas and electricity firms are hoarding up to £2bn from people who pay by direct debit.

He will use a meeting with company bosses to ask about reports they are making £36m a year from interest alone because many customers are paying too much when they are automatically charged an estimated amount for their gas and electricity each month.

A source close to Barker said he will demand the energy companies – British Gas, SSE, Scottish Power, EDF, E.ON and npower – declare how much consumer credit they are sitting on and how many of their customers are in credit.

On Monday night he said it was vital people who paid by direct debt were not "being unknowingly ripped off".

"The better energy companies will now automatically refund your cash if you build up more money than required to meet your normal bill or will pay you interest if you are in surplus," he said. "However, it looks like some companies aren't doing that and I am determined to get consumers a better deal and call time on the big six sitting on customers' cash."

It comes after the Guardian saw figures showing npower stockpiled £400m at one point last year from customers, while British Gas put £20m in "credit balances" into its annual account in one recent financial year.

Following those revelations, the minister will ask companies to pay interest to customers who are in surplus, following the lead of some small suppliers, including Ovo Energy, which pays 3% interest on credit balances.

Meanwhile Owen Paterson, the environment secretary, has written to water companies to "stress the crucial role that the industry can play to bring costs down" for households.

He will ask the companies to consider if they need to apply the full price increases allowed by the regulator next year, which are likely to be around £12 on the average £388 annual bill. The companies are also being urged to bring in "social tariffs" with discounts for households who are struggling to pay.

The coalition has been searching for ways to reduce household bills after Ed Miliband attacked the government for its failure to act on the "cost of living crisis" and offered to freeze gas and electricity prices if he wins power in 2015.

However, Labour is likely to criticise the government for asking utility companies to change their ways on a voluntary basis, rather than forcing them with laws to treat their customers better.

"More than two million households, over one in 10, now spend more than 5% of their income on water according to the regulator and customers in Britain face some of the highest bills in Europe," said Maria Eagle, Labour's shadow environment secretary. "Yet David Cameron still refuses to require water companies to introduce a social tariff to help those who are struggling, even though only three companies have introduced such a scheme under the current voluntary arrangement."

Our selection of best buys

Lender Initial rate
HSBC 1.49% More
Post Office 1.63% More
HSBC 1.69% More
Name BT Rate BT Period
BARCLAYCARD Platinum Credit Card with Extended Balance Transfer 0.00% 30 months More
BARCLAYCARD Platinum Credit Card with Balance Transfer 0.00% 28 months More
TESCO BANK Clubcard Credit Card for balance transfers 0.00% 28 months More
Provider Headline rate APR
Sainsbury's Shopper Standard Loan 4.90% 4.9% More
Derbyshire Personal Loan 5.00% 5% More
Sainsbury's Shopper Reward Loan 5.10% 5.1% More
Provider AER
BM Savings 1.7% More
AA 1.6% More
Coventry Building Society 1.6% More

Today's best video

  • Ripper Street

    Halloween TV review

    Telly addict Andrew Collins reviews Ripper Street (above), Dracula and American Horror Story: Coven
  • mid-air collision

    Skydivers survive mid-air plane collision

    Nine skydivers and two pilots survived a plane crash 12,000ft above Wisconsin
  • Mars Orbiter blasts off

    India launches rocket to Mars

    Unmanned spacecraft to reach red planet's orbit in September 2014
  • black cat

    Is superstition irrational?

    Giles Fraser and Tracy King discuss the role of ritual in modern life
  • The NSA files trailblock image

    Live: Follow NSA-related developments as controversy over leaks continues to make headlines

Today in pictures